This month's newsletter has been posted. There are NO CHANGES in any of the models.
Moving the chains: Crypto gets a new set of downs
Super Bowl LVII was that rare occasion when the game was more interesting than the ads.
Remember last year’s Super Bowl commercials? How many of them were for cryptocurrency exchanges or related entities? eToro, Crypto.com, Coinbase’s bouncing QR code … none of them aged well. Most embarrassing of all, though, was comedian Larry David’s pitch for FTX.
“… and the money you invest in FTX goes in this end.” Credit: Dentsu McgarryBowen
The name of the spot was “Don’t Miss Out,” and that was the whole point. Forget about crypto use cases. Who cares about fundamentals? How do you even arrive at a valuation? None of that’s important. All that matters is this: Taking a pass on crypto is like taking a pass on the light bulb, the wheel or indoor plumbing.
There were no blockchain ads on Super Sunday this year, but that doesn’t mean the entire asset class has gone away. It suffered from the latest of a string of “crypto winters” but appears to be recovering. It just doesn’t play well in cold weather. Dallas Cowboys fans know what that’s like.
Frozen assets
The term “crypto winter” originally referred to a period from mid-December 2017 to late March 2018 when Bitcoin Core, after a yearlong bull run, lost almost two-thirds of its value. The price of the most widely traded token steadied but then, come November 2018, it tanked again and stayed down until, once more, the market thawed in late March. It looked like Bitcoin was going to weather the winter of 2019-2020 fairly well, but then came Covid-19. Still, by the end of 2020, Bitcoin was trading at $40,000, and it just kept running. At its peak – mid-November of course, 2021 – it was closing in on $69,000.
By the time of the 2022 Super Bowl, Bitcoin had given up all its 2021 gains and was back to the $40,000 neighborhood. Of course, there were a lot of people – including FTX CEO Sam Bankman-Fried – who’d advise you to buy on the dip.
Today, Bitcoin is trading around $23,000, which is still higher than it was at the run-up to that first crypto winter.
Let’s sketch that out with a fever chart:
Bitcoin’s series of crypto winters, linear view. Credit: Yahoo Finance
Bitcoin has a way of getting knocked down, but not out. Still, maybe this isn’t the best way to understand Bitcoin’s dynamics. Let’s look at it from the logarithmic view – that is, a chart where there’s equal space between $10, $100 and $1,000, rather than equal space between $10, $11 and $12. The log scale helps us visualize percentage change more clearly.
Bitcoin’s series of crypto winters, log view. Credit: Yahoo Finance
From this perspective, it looks more like Bitcoin rises fast, ratchets up, falls back and regroups, over and over again.
Sometimes there’s a concrete reason for it. Sometimes there isn’t. The first crypto winter was just a matter of irrational exuberance. The market was simply oversold.
But then you sometimes get an external shock, such as the collapse of FTX.
In Math Nerds We Trust
The dollar isn’t backed by anything real. It’s just a note written against the full faith and credit of the U.S. government. But we’re not seeing much of either lately. A University of California study tracked 50 years of Gallup and Harris polling showing how the American people have lost faith in institutions across the board, and government institutions specifically. Then all you have to do is tune in to the debt ceiling fight now going on in Congress to call the nation’s credit into question.
People can be forgiven for thinking that just maybe there’s a better way to imagine money. And that’s why we editors of this newsletter are not as dismissive of crypto as are a lot of people in the financial services industry. But even so, we all must put our collective faith in something or someone.
For a lot of crypto enthusiasts, that person was Bankman-Fried. Literally born on the Stanford University campus, he spent his high school summers at math camp then went off to college at MIT. He then went to work for Jane Street Capital where his job was buying and selling international exchange-traded funds. While there, he figured out how to take advantage of the widely known fact that cryptocurrencies tend to trade at different price points on different exchanges. So, he ditched Jane Street and opened up Alameda Research.
That’s where Bankman-Fried realized that, as much money as there is to make in crypto arbitrage, there’s more to be made by owning an exchange. So, he set up FTX.
We’re not saying it was a scam from the start, but let’s break it down. First, FTX was substantively owned by Bankman-Fried and run like a one-man show with a board of crony directors. Second, it was based in the Bahamas and incorporated in Antigua and Barbuda – as one does when one believes it’s easier to skirt U.S. regulations than to adhere to them. Third, it was intrinsically connected with Alameda Research – which was also incorporated offshore. If there’s one thing a quantitative trading firm that thrives on volatility is known to do, it’s posting short-term losses. Alameda’s entire model is high risk, high reward. With nobody looking at the relationship between the exchange and its leading market maker, and all internal accounts denominated in the FTT token that drew its value directly from FTX, shenanigans inevitably ensued. It was just a matter of when and how blatantly. And as soon as the crypto market deflated enough that Alameda needed funds to cover ill-advised positions, those shenanigans quickly ran into the billions of dollars. FTX went bankrupt, investors’ money evaporated and Bankman-Fried was extradited to the U.S. to face fraud charges.
Larry David is hilarious, but maybe we shouldn’t have been taking investment advice from him.
The point after
In the wake of FTX’s collapse, just as in the first crypto winter, Bitcoin lost two-thirds of its value. And then – this is the important part – it recovered. As goofy an idea as cryptocurrency may seem to some, it apparently has some inherent value or it wouldn’t keep rebounding like this.
Of course, FTX is not the only place to trade crypto. At least one other crypto exchange, Coinbase, endeavors to be treated like any other American financial services provider and strives to stay inside the lines of compliance. It’s having its struggles at the moment, but so’s the whole tech sector. And Binance, the world’s largest crypto exchange, has a U.S. unit that also takes pains to stay in Washington’s good graces.
We should also note that FTX wasn’t the first crypto exchange to go belly-up. In 2014, Tokyo-based Mt. Gox handled 70% of all Bitcoin transactions worldwide – until suddenly it didn’t. Was its liquidation forced by theft? Trading losses? Managerial incompetence? It was probably a mix of several factors and we’ll never know the precise proportions. We can only be guided by Hanlon’s razor: "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity." You might have guessed by now the effect the Mt. Gox fiasco had on the price of Bitcoin: down by two-thirds, followed by a recovery that soared to new highs.
Is Bitcoin fated to bounce out of this trough? Is a six-digit valuation inevitable? And what about Ethereum, XRP or any of the other cryptocurrencies that remain relevant players in the crypto universe? For that matter, are non-fungible tokens, or NTFs, a fad that has passed or will they be making a comeback as well? Nobody knows for sure, but a trusted financial advisor could help you design a playbook to handle any contingency.
FedEx pilots, are you maximizing your retirement savings?
Watch this short video to find out how Smith Anglin can help you do just that.
Gross domestic product increased at an annual rate of 2.9% in 2022’s fourth quarter, according to the initial estimate released by the Commerce Department’s Bureau of Economic Analysis. While this represents a slowdown from the third quarter’s 3.2% rate, it still reflects relatively healthy economic growth. Increases in private inventories, consumer spending, government spending and nonresidential fixed investment accounted for the expansion. For the full year, the U.S. economy improved 2.1% in 2022, representing a return to post-recession/pre-Covid normalcy.
Total nonfarm payroll employment in the U.S. grew by an unexpected 517,000 jobs in January. The unemployment rate dipped from 3.5% to 3.4%. While that is not a huge decrease, it does constitute the lowest level of joblessness since 1969. Despite high-profile layoffs in Silicon Valley, the broader job market – including that for tech skills – continued to expand. The labor force participation rate was little changed at 62.4%.
Initial jobless claims decreased by 3,000 to 183,000, seasonally adjusted, in the week ending January 28. The four-week moving average, which removes volatility, decreased by 5,750 to 197,500.
The Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers rose 0.5% in January on a seasonally adjusted basis, according to the Labor Department, a sharp contrast from December’s minimal 0.1%. Over the last 12 months, the all-items index increased 6.4% before seasonal adjustment, compared to 6.5% for calendar year 2022. Shelter was by far the largest contributor to the monthly all items increase, accounting for nearly half of the monthly all items increase, while food, gasoline, and natural gas also contributed. With these volatile prices taken out of the equation, core CPI rose 0.4% in January, or 5.6% for the trailing 12 months.
US Stocks
The S&P 500 started the year strong, gaining +6.3% on a total-return basis in January. The CBOE VIX “fear gauge” dropped 10.5% for the month, ending AT 19.40, very close to post-Covid lows. This suggests investors may be gathering renewed confidence in the market.
International
Stock markets around the world also shook off 2022’s sour mood. In Europe, Frankfurt’s DAX, Amsterdam’s Euronext 100 and London’s FTSE 100 improved +8.7%, +7.7%, +10.7% and +4.5% respectively in January.
In Asia, Hong Kong’s Hang Seng, Tokyo’s Nikkei 225 and Shanghai’s SSE Composite gained +10.7%, +6.3% and +5.4% respectively.
Central Banks
It wasn’t pretty, but the Federal Reserve might have managed to raise interest rates just enough to stave off hyperinflation without triggering a recession. It’s too early to declare victory, but the Fed no longer feels the need to jack up the cost of capital as severely as it did last year.
It’s still raising rates, but February 1’s modest quarter-percent hike is manageable compared to 2022’s four three-quarter percent, two half-percent and one other quarter-percent moves. You might ask: When will the Fed start lowering rates? The answer is: Not in the immediate future. According to subsequent comments from Fed Chair Jay Powell, “ongoing increases will be appropriate” to achieve the goal of tamping the annual rate down to 2%.
Commodities
West Texas Intermediate crude prices rose +7.8% in January to end the month at $78.87 per barrel.
The price of gold rose +6.5% last month, ending at $1,945.30 per ounce.
Currencies continued to advance against the dollar as the greenback dropped -1.8%, -1.5% and -0.8% in London, Frankfurt and Tokyo respectively in January.
Cryptocurrency seems to be recovering from its doldrums, as noted above. Bitcoin, the bellwether token, rebounded +38.7% in January, ending the month at $23,099.90
Trading Restrictions Reminder!
Your 401k plan has trading restrictions, so you must keep track of your buy and sell orders. Not paying attention could leave you locked out of trading.
Fear & Greed Index
Bull Bear Oscillator vs. S&P 500 Index
This month’s models are now available to subscribers. If you are interested in becoming an Airline subscriber, click here or please contact us at 1-717-569-8162 or email us at airways@uspfa.org.
From the Captain's Table
Minimizing income tax’s hidden cost: the time it takes to file
We can discuss – or even argue passionately – about the proper scope, size and role of government. But you can’t look at Somalia or Haiti or Yemen or some other failed state and say, “Wow! Those folks really have their act together!” Is government a “necessary evil”? Let’s leave the “evil” part to philosophers, but it is certainly necessary. And that means it’s incumbent on all of us to support it, even if grudgingly, with taxes.
And again, there is a debate to be had about how to best levy those taxes. Congress’s Ways and Means Committee is currently looking at abolishing the Internal Revenue Service and replacing the income tax with a national sales tax. That’s probably going nowhere. Monetarist icon Milton Friedman called a tax on land “the least-bad tax” in this video. That’s quite an endorsement from a freshwater economist, but it likewise went nowhere. (Economists in general eschew the conservative and liberal labels. American economists are said to be of two species: freshwater – from the heartland – and saltwater – from the coasts.)
For the foreseeable future, it looks like we’re stuck with the income tax. And as long as we want such perceived virtues as home ownership, securities investment, marriage, saving for college or retirement, forming a business, and so on to be rewarded with preferential tax treatment, we’re stuck with stacks upon stacks of tax forms to prove that we qualify. And because most of us don’t think working through tax forms is much fun, we’re stuck with hiring accountants to do that for us.
Maybe the best we can do at present is figure out how to streamline and optimize the taxation process. How can we get our taxes done as simply and easily as we can? What do our accountants need from us? What is excess information that they have to sort through, wasting their time and our money? And how do we get our tax refunds – if any – back as quickly as possible?
Just answer the questions
No matter how complicated your taxes – how many forms and schedules get paperclipped together – completing your tax return is really just a matter of filling in the blanks. Anything you tell your accountant that doesn’t help to fill in a blank is likely a waste of everyone’s effort.
A good accounting firm will provide you – ideally by electronic media but at least by First Class mail – a checklist or worksheet to help you focus on what’s really important. You should have gotten it by the end of January or in early February.
It’ll ask you about whether certain special events happened in your life during the preceding year. Did someone in your family need long-term care? Did you make tax-advantaged contributions to a college fund? Did you convert your traditional IRA to a Roth? Did you get married? Did you have another child, or did one of your children become independent? Did you change addresses? Questions like that.
The checklist will also include a litany of questions about:
healthcare coverage,
income,
purchases, sales and debt,
retirement plans,
education,
itemized deductions such as charitable donations, business expenses or disaster losses, and
miscellaneous items such as foreign investments, household employees or cryptocurrency investment.
It’s best to just answer the questions your accountant asked. There’s no need to go into gnat’s-eye detail about every $20 cash withdrawal you made from the ATM – and definitely no need to submit every receipt. It’s still good practice to save receipts in case the IRS comes knocking; still, your accountant probably doesn’t want to see them. It’s just too much detail that’s usually not necessary.
A good-faith estimate of your medical expenses, charitable donations, moving expenses and most business expenses including use of your home and vehicle always helps. But it’s got to be close enough that both you and your tax preparer are comfortable putting your names to it. Often it’s helpful to look to your previous years’ returns for guidance.
What you absolutely will need to provide to your accountant, though, is documentation of your income. These generally take the form of W-2s from companies that withhold taxes from paychecks and 1099s for companies that don’t. W-2s are generally from companies which formally employ you. If you hit it big at a casino, you might also receive a W-2G. Different flavors of 1099s reflect different forms of payment from gig-economy income, interest, dividends, retirement plans, sales of stock, sales of real estate and government benefits.
You might also need to provide a Form 1098 to deduct interest paid on mortgages or student loans.
These W-2s, 1099s and 1098s usually all arrive in your mailbox or email inbox by the end of January. Since taxes aren’t due until April, you should be good. So, take a little time to get it all squared away, but don’t take too much time. Try to have it all submitted to your accountant by the end of February to avoid the crunch.
Taxing times
You’re probably aware of artificial intelligences that can write a college essay on Franz Kafka or paint an Impressionist portrait of your dog. There will come a day when one can do your taxes. Until that day comes, though, your green-eyeshaded accountants will be taking care of this task.
Accountants do have technological help, of course. There are many brands of tax software programs on the market, and every accounting firm has its preference. These packages are very helpful, but there’s still the need for a human touch. Software isn’t going to call you up and ask if you might be missing $150 in deductions because that’s all you need to drop down to a lower tax bracket. While a lot of tax prep work is an exercise in data entry, there is so much more to it.
The software must of course be mathematically accurate and updated regularly to comply with the ever-changing tax code. That is the most important thing, but not the only important thing. Protecting your personal data is also crucial. This data is inside your accounting firm’s internal network, so that must be hardened against encroachment. But data must also be guarded when it’s in transit. You don’t want to be swapping files via email, which is notoriously risky from a cyber security point of view. Ideally, you want your tax return posted to a secure repository online, downloadable to you alone.
Whatever tax software your accountant uses, it has a gateway to the IRS. You should use it. By giving your accountant permission to electronically file, then providing your bank’s routing and account numbers, you speed up processing of your refund from one or two weeks to as little as one or two days.
Net profits
All this advice is just for guidance. The connection between a taxpayer and an accountant is about as personal a professional relationship as you can have without a stethoscope. Take the time to ask your accountant how to proceed with getting your taxes in order. And listen to your accountant’s advice when it comes to selecting a financial advisor who can maximize your tax-shielded dividend and interest income.
-Steve
Steve Anglin, CPA
Managing Partner
Steve Anglin, CPA is a Managing Partner at Smith Anglin Financial, and the Head of the Tax Preparation Services. He is also responsible for Smith Anglin’s compliance supervision. He holds a BBA in Accounting and a BBA in Real Estate, and numerous securities licenses and designations.